Traffic Engineering
DU Zhi-gang, MEI Jia-lin, HE Shi-ming, DING Xu, MA Ao-jun
The entrances and exits of expressway tunnels often cause drastic changes in visual space and illuminance, which easily trigger “black-hole” and “white-hole” effects. The interior sections of tunnels are characterized by monotonous visual environments and a lack of reference objects, leading to “spatiotemporal tunnel” and “sidewall” effects. Tunnel groups and spiral tunnels are prone to inducing the “whipping effect” and “psychological rotation effect,” respectively. These negative psychological effects significantly interfere with drivers' perceptions and judgments, provoke inappropriate driving behaviors, and reduce traffic safety. Based on the logical chain of “tunnel visual environment-negative psychological effects-inappropriate driving behaviors-reconstruction of visual reference system-optimization strategies,” a framework for analyzing and regulating drivers' negative psychological effects was constructed. The relationship between the visual environment and negative psychological effects was explored, regulatory strategies were proposed, and methods for optimizing and evaluating visual reference systems were summarized. The results indicate that drivers' negative psychological effects mainly originate from drastic changes in the visual reference system at tunnel entrances and exits and from the lack of variation in the weak visual reference system within the interior section. Ordinary tunnels should upgrade their basic visual reference system to a safe or comfortable type; extra-long tunnels and connection sections of tunnel groups should adopt a rhythmic visual reference system; and spiral tunnels (and tunnel groups) require a constant, stable, continuous, and redundant visual reference system. Regulation strategies include clarifying the spatial right-of-way, aligning with drivers' perceptual needs, decomposing driving tasks, enhancing comfort and rhythm, and introducing linear visual guidance and curve-constant delineation systems. Shading facilities, lighting installations, visual guidance devices, landscaping, interior decorations, and pavement treatments can effectively optimize the visual environment. However, their design parameters require further systematic investigation. Currently, the evaluation of visual reference systems lacks a unified index system and methodology, and should integrate optical parameters with human factor indicators, including visual perception, visual characteristics, physiological responses, and driving behaviors. In the future, evaluation systems and optimization strategies should be improved through engineering case studies to support the development of safe, energy-efficient, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasing tunnel environments.